Search  
  Forum  
Racism with Chinese Characteristics?
Post time: 16-Nov-2007  17:24

Teaching university students in Shanghai gave me a unique opportunity to explore the opinions of the youth on race issues and the significance of skin color. I once taught a class on racism. One student shot up his hand and said wisely, "We don't have racism in China, because we don't have black people."

My students were shocked on discover that my boyfriend was "black" (as a North American who spent a year studying in South Africa, I'm cautious about using the term "black" to refer to a person of African descent, but I will use the term here for the sake of simplicity). "Black skin is ugly," was a common complaint. My female students said they would never date a black guy because the color of their skin is unattractive. It seemed not so much an issue of racism, but of cultural standards of beauty. White skin is considered beautiful and black just happens to be the opposite of white. When attempting to purchase a moisturizer or skin cleanser in China, it is difficult to find anything that doesn't advertise and contain "skin whitening" ingredients. In Western countries, we are accustomed to see "whitening" on tubes of tooth paste, but not skin care products. I laughed when my boyfriend complained about his mistaken purchase of "whitening" Neutrogena moisturizer. "What? Like I WANT to look like Michael Jackson?" he growled. 

Chinese girls cower under the rays of the sun, like vampires at dawn. The umbrellas are pulled out to shade them and in the absence of an umbrella, they will school books, bags or jackets over their heads to shield themselves from a pleasant sunny day. You might identify umbrella use with rainy days, but in China, come rain or sunshine, the umbrellas are always out. So why the obsession with fish-belly white skin? Well, in Victorian times, white skin was all the rage amongst the European aristocracy. They powdered their faces. White skin was evidence that you could afford a life of leisure, whereas a tan showed you labored in the sun like the peasants. In China, the farmers and migrant workers have deeply tanned skin. Dark skin is indicative of a lower class. 

And while white skin is popular for Chinese, all the expats rush to the solariums to get their tans at 90 RMB for 12 minutes (I am embarrassed to know this). Caucasians feed an equally large industry on skin care products to become brown as Asians have to stay white. Beauty really is in the eye of the beholder and one's culture and upbringing have a lot to do with concepts of beauty. It may take some time before black is considered beautiful in China, but things are changing. Basketball stars are revered in China (most of whom are black). Recently Beyonce, an African American singer came to perform in Shanghai to a sold out audience, many of whom were Chinese. Yesterday my African American friend was visiting. He is a model, dancer, jazz singer and events planner. When he walks down the street, he gets so much attention that sometimes, he just wants to hide. Yesterday, he pulled his hoodie over his head, in an attempt to hide from the stares. At a stop light, he looked down to meet the curious perusal of a six-year old boy. The child pointed up at him and said "monkey" in English. He looked at the child's mother in shock. She just shrugged and grinned back. This was the straw that broke the "monkey's" back. The childlike innocence of the comment made him outraged, hurt and deeply offended at the same time. "You see black man, you see monkey," he groaned. To read more about the experiences of African Americans in China check out the blog: The Black China Hand (go here if you have problems with the other link).

[Last edited by lion lady on 6-Mar-2008  10:47]

Share

Post by: antony  Time: 28-Dec-2007  14:21
The child pointed up at him and said "monkey" in English.Girls in China donot like black people,that doesnot means they hate black people.because in China,we are all yellow skin,so strange doesnot equal Hate,or what they called"Racism"
Post by: stemsee  Time: 24-Jun-2008  23:30
You are not all yellow skinned. Most of you are brown skinned. Here in Nanning I was told by a close friend of Nanning government leader that no chinese man in Nanning likes a black person; in fact he is a teacher in a very important school in Guangxi. At this time I have friends of all colours and walks of life and I have heard many complaints about the treatment foreigners are experiencing in nanning these days. It is like a second boxer rebellion. Everywhere foreigners go to sit down and eat five minutes later four or five chinese men follow and sit themselves as close to the foreigners as they can and then start talking very loudly and provocatively. Offering insults about any chinese friends who are with the foreigners. It is as though the Guangxi authorities have set in motion a widespread anti-foreigner campaign, designed to upset everyone in contact with foreigners. I myself know of several foreigners who have been assaulted, including myself, by government officials and their henchmen. The police fail to catch anyone or even do not turn up when called! I hope our governments are paying close attention to the developing situation here in Nanning. These goverment thugs will get away with everything if foreigners do not organise themselves with support from their governments. I wonder how would these cowardly people like it if our countrymen treated the chinese abroad in the same way! Look at how the chinese responded to the non-racist remarks made by a CNN news reader! The Chinese do not know the difference between a racist comment and an opinionised fact. Yet they are able to react inappropriately all over the world. We need to highlight and contain chinese hypocracy before it contaminates our advanced free thinking/speaking societies. Amen
Post by: lion lady  Time: 25-Jun-2008  13:25
@ stemsee,

I think China, like any other large nation, suffers from a fair dose of racism and xenophobia.

The reason I wrote this article, was because I was so amused by the words of my student: "We don't have racism in China because we don't have black people." What a loaded statement.

I suppose the first step is to acknowledge/identify that there is a problem before it can be fixed or, at least, improved. Thank you for your comments.
Post by: stemsee  Time: 30-Jun-2008  13:57
Yes it is an over loaded statement! And how did it get piled up? The Chinese racists necessarily place themselves second only to whites in terms of operceived cultural or racial superiority! Hence girls and men with umbrellas; no one wants to get kissed by the sun! Those racists are usually persons with money and some travel experience. Maybe they themselves experienced a feeling of secondary citizenship in the human race. My personal experience teaches me that most peple in China are not genuinely racist. There is simply a lack of exposure to non-white people. That is a lack of experience and therefore a lack of understanding about black skinned people. Together with film and music culture offering negative reenforcment of racial stereotypes which does nothing to alleviate the situation. True communism is not racist! I think Chairman Mao would have supported that statment. The fight against negative racism has to be fought in education. How? Well I had to introduce the word brown to my grade 2 students there was nothing to point at except my own skin, which I did! 'My face is brown.'' My assistant female chinese teacher looked at the ground, staring distantly; she didn't want to join in! But many of my best students did! I am brown too, they said joyfully and proudly, happy to share something so personal in common with thier favourite English teacher! One myth down.